Fidgeting in class is extremely common — and increasingly, research suggests it is not a sign of distraction but often a strategy to maintain attention. Children who fidget are often trying to generate enough sensory stimulation to stay at their optimal arousal level. The key question is not "how do I stop my child from fidgeting?" but "how can I give them a better way to fidget?"
Key Takeaways
- Fidgeting is common — and often useful: it may help children maintain focus
- Stalvey & Brasell (2006): stress balls improved reading comprehension in restless children
- Van der Wurff & Meijs (2021): children who self-initiate sensory tool use benefit more than those who are instructed to use it
- The difference between helpful and disruptive fidgeting is whether it interferes with the child's own work or disturbs others
- Chewing has a hands-free advantage over hand fidgets: the child can write, draw, and type simultaneously
- For children with ADHD, fidgeting may actually help — suppressing it may worsen focus
Why Do Children Fidget?
Fidgeting — moving some part of the body (foot, hands, body) in a repetitive, semi-automatic way during a sedentary task — is a nearly universal human behaviour. Children fidget more than adults, and children with ADHD, autism, or sensory processing differences tend to fidget more than their neurotypical peers.
The traditional view was that fidgeting indicated distraction and should be stopped. The emerging view, supported by research, is that fidgeting often serves a regulatory function — it generates sensory input that helps the nervous system stay at an optimal level of arousal for the task at hand. A child who bounces their leg while working may actually be performing better than they would if they sat perfectly still.
What Does the Research Say?
Stalvey & Brasell (2006)
This study gave children identified as "restless or inattentive" the use of a stress ball during reading lessons. The children who used the stress balls showed improved legibility of writing and reading comprehension compared to control conditions. The researchers proposed that the tactile input from the stress ball helped maintain optimal arousal for learning.
Van der Wurff & Meijs (2021)
This study looked at sensory processing tools in children and their effects on attention and arithmetic. The key finding: children who self-initiated tool use — picking up the tool when they felt the need — benefited more than those who were instructed to use it at set times. The practical implication is that access matters more than instruction: give a child a sensory tool and let them decide when to use it.
Fidgeting vs Distraction — What's the Difference?
The critical distinction is not whether a child is moving — it is whether that movement is interfering with their own work or disturbing others. A child who bounces their leg, wiggles in their seat, or chews on something while their eyes remain on the board and their hand continues writing is fidgeting helpfully. A child who is spinning a fidget spinner in view of peers, dropping things on the floor, or making noise while others are trying to work is fidgeting disruptively.
The goal is to channel the fidgeting impulse toward forms that are:
- Silent
- Invisible or minimally visible to others
- Hands-free (or at least not requiring sustained hand use that prevents writing)
- Always available
The Chewing Advantage Over Hand Fidgets
Fidget toys — spinners, cubes, rings — provide proprioceptive input through the hands. This is valuable, but it has a practical limitation: the hands are also needed for school work. Writing, drawing, typing, and using classroom equipment all require hand use. A child who is manipulating a fidget toy in one hand while writing with the other is using the dominant hand for sensory regulation rather than for work, or is making compromises in either the writing or the fidgeting.
A chew necklace, by contrast, provides proprioceptive input through the jaw — which does not compete with hand tasks. A child can write with both hands, draw, type, or use equipment while simultaneously chewing, because the mouth and hands operate independently. This hands-free advantage makes the chew necklace particularly useful in academic settings.
Interested in both options? Read our comparison of chew necklaces and fidget toys.
Chew Necklace vs Fidget Toys →Related Articles
References
- Stalvey S & Brasell H (2006). Using stress balls to focus the attention of sixth-grade learners. Journal of At-Risk Issues.
- Van der Wurff I & Meijs C (2021). Sensory processing tools in children: effects on attention and arithmetic. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 209, 105143.